Evan Hunter was a Writer.
He sold millions of books over a career that spanned more than half a century, producing more than one hundred novels as well as dozens of short stories and developing a readership that devotedly looked forward to each of his new books.
For literary works aimed at the bestseller lists — a total of 32 — he wrote as Evan Hunter. But, for genre novels, he used a variety of pen names.
Of course, Evan Hunter itself was a kind of pen name. He was born Salvatore Albert Lombino on October 15, 1926, and published his first short story and first novel (Reaching for the Moon) in 1951 as S.A. Lombino. But, as he explained to me in a phone interview once, Lombino sounded too ethnic for mid-century America. So, in 1952, he took Evan Hunter as his legal name.
But Hunter wrote genre novels as well. In the beginning, there were several science fiction works for young adults. Mostly, though, he wrote crime novels of one sort or another.
In fact, Hunter, under his pseudonym Ed McBain, is credited with creating the police procedural with his 87th Precinct series. By the time of Hunter’s death in 2005, he had published 55 of these books focusing on a squadroom of detectives in a metropolis very much like New York City.
As McBain, he wrote 19 other crime novels unrelated to the 87th Precinct investigators. And, in at least 10 cases, novels he wrote with other pen names were reissued with McBain as the author.
All of which is to say that Evan Hunter was a very good writer who was very successful at what he did.
And then there is the novel Scimitar that he published in 1992 as John Abbott.
OK
Hunter never used the Abbott pen name again, and he never claimed the book for McBain or for himself.
Although Scimitar was issued the next year in paperback, it seems to have faded away very quickly, never to be reprinted (although in 2016 there was a Kindle edition).
Scimitar was Hunter’s sole foray into the spy thriller, and, truth be told, it was only OK.
OK, for most writers, would have been, well, OK. Hunter, however, was such a skillful writer of crime novels as well as bestsellers that Scimitar is a real disappointment.
The old college try
It’s the story of a Libyan spy cell in the United States that is activated to assassinate President George H.W. Bush in New York City around the Fourth of July. Its focus is on Sonny (full name: Krishnan Henkar), a student doctor at a Los Angeles hospital and a trained killer.
And Hunter as Abbott gives it the old college try. For instance, every once in a while, he shows that he’s got the thriller tone well in hand:
Sonny did not place the first of his three calls until three o’clock that Friday afternoon.
By that time, he knew exactly how he would kill the President.
“A wire garrote”
Abbott follows Sonny across the U.S. to get his terrorist assignment and then to develop his plans for getting to Bush either at a Canadian embassy ball or at a Statue of Liberty speech.
These plans involve mixing a bunch of chemicals to create the deadly nerve agent sarin while, here and there, killing an inconvenient cop or civilian (such as with an ice pick to the eye) and bedding a beautiful woman every now and again (including — separately — a mother and daughter).
Along the way, Abbott provides Sonny’s bona-fides:
- He’d used a wire garrote the first time he’d killed anyone.
- By the time he was seventeen, he had killed three men. By the time he was twenty—and an undergraduate at Princeton—he had killed yet another person, a girl this time.
A small green tattoo
Members of the terrorist cell wear a small green tattoo of a scimitar (curved sword) under their left breast which seems, to this reader at least, self-defeating since these tattoos end up providing the cops and federal agents with clue to help them hone in on Sonny.
Also, there’s that huge coincidence — the 29-year-old Sonny goes to bed on a train with a beautiful but a bit flighty 19-year-old and then, in a spectacular Cape Cod beach house, sleeps with a strikingly attractive 39-year-old woman who, unknown to him, is the girl’s mother. It’s a bit much.
Yet, spy thrillers are often built on such stuff. With the right pace and sharp enough plot lines, a thriller writer is often able to paper over holes in the story.
Quirky characters
But that’s the problem with Scimitar. Abbott — who, as Hunter or McBain, is skillful at building a story that draws the reader along to the twist of a conclusion — is more than a bit ham-handed.
Abbott spends too much time and space on the obtaining and mixing of the sarin chemicals. He’s got several subplots that end abruptly — often with murder — and one bigger subplot that takes too much time and distracts too much from Sonny.
In fact, I had the sense that, ironically, Abbott was done in by a talent that Hunter and McBain used regularly to give life to their novels — i.e., turning characters into complex (and interesting) human beings.
In an 87th Precinct novel, a quirky character gave the plot a freshness and distinctiveness. In a thriller, however, the details needed to give life to a character take away from the propulsion of the plot.
Instead of being pulled along from this twist to that twist, this surprise to that surprise, Abbott’s reader is slowed down to get to know, for example, a cop who’s later going to be found dead in a laundry cart.
Plodding instead of sprinting
Also, Abbott’s story gets way too complex at the end so the final pages are plodding when they need to be sprinting.
Scimitar isn’t as bad as I’m making it sound. It is, as I’ve said, OK.
Nonetheless, there’s a reason Abbott never published another spy novel. He definitely was no Evan Hunter or Ed McBain.
Patrick T. Reardon
10.9.26
Written by : Patrick T. Reardon
For more than three decades Patrick T. Reardon was an urban affairs writer, a feature writer, a columnist, and an editor for the Chicago Tribune. In 2000 he was one of a team of 50 staff members who won a Pulitzer Prize for explanatory reporting. Now a freelance writer and poet, he has contributed chapters to several books and is the author of Faith Stripped to Its Essence. His website is https://patricktreardon.com/.
